ZAPRASZA.net POLSKA ZAPRASZA KRAKÓW ZAPRASZA TV ZAPRASZA ART ZAPRASZA
Dodaj artykuł  

KIM JESTEŚMY ARTYKUŁY CIEKAWE LINKI 2002-2009 NASZ PATRONAT KRONIKA KRAKOWA DZIŚ W POLSCE

Inne artykuły

Jak strącono samolot pod Smoleńskiem 
15 wrzesień 2010      Artur Łoboda
Skojarzenie: 9-11 w Centralnej Europie i 9-11 w USA 
10 listopad 2009      MG
Polsce potrzebna grupa specjalsitow a nie nowe partyjki 
17 maj 2015      Bars
Jak to na zielonej wyspie bywa... 
15 listopad 2014      www.polskawalczaca.com
EuroMajdan - krok ku demokracji czy dyktaturze? 
19 listopad 2014      Stowarzyszenie Wspólnota Polska
"Mniejsze zło" - Wybory 2011 
8 padziernik 2011      Artur Łoboda
Dlaczego ludzie są teraz takimi dupkami? 
24 padziernik 2014      www.polskawalczaca.com
Na prawo od lewej 
17 styczeń 2015      Artur Łoboda
CO JA ZROBIŁAM NAJLEPSZEGO ? /z teki Teatru ESSE/ 
29 styczeń 2014      -/ Ewa Englert-Sanakiewicz
Więcej bezprawia - niż Prawa 
24 wrzesień 2017     
Manifestacja ND 11 listopada 2014 roku w Krakowie (2) 
12 listopad 2014      Artur Łoboda
Nad Polską zapanują ciemności. 
20 sierpień 2014      www.polskawalczaca.com
Katy Carr - Kocham cię Janku 
16 czerwiec 2016     
W czyim interesie Kaczyński pojechał na Ukrainę? 
2 grudzień 2013      Artur Łoboda
Wielka wtopa 1 
15 listopad 2011      Artur Łoboda
Przypadek Orwella w historii cywilizacji 
14 luty 2012      Artur Łoboda
Rząd, który niczego się nie uczy 
11 luty 2017      Artur Łoboda
Żenujący spektakl w TVP "Studio Polska" 
10 lipiec 2017      Artur Łoboda
Spotkanie zwolenników JOW - Lubin 27.06.2015 
29 czerwiec 2015      Artur Łoboda
Stalinowska szkoła filmu historycznego 
26 wrzesień 2013      Artur Łoboda

 
 

Slavic and East European Journal


Spring 2010

Book Review

Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski. Poland: An Illustrated History. New York: Hippocrene Books, 2008. Illustrations. Index. 282 pp. $19.95 (cloth).

With this work, Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski makes a valuable contribution to Hippocrene Books' long list of publications on Polish history and culture. Pogonowski -- trained as a scientist and identified as a lexicographer-writer on the book's back cover -- is also the author of Jews in Poland: A Documentary History (Hippocrene Books,1997) and Polish-English dictionaries. This most recent book, Poland: An Illustrated History, covers more than a thousand years of Polish history in fewer than three hundred pages. The result of Pogonowski's ambitious attempt is admirable. All major historical figures and events are mentioned. Political and social issues are aptly discussed, and cultural history is very much an integral part of the book. Overall, the book is written in a clear and concise way, which makes it easy for all audiences to read.

The book is divided into many short chapters, ranging from one to a few dozen pages. It also contains maps, timelines of Polish history, lists of Nobel Prize winners born in Poland, and an index of key figures and events mentioned throughout the book. A highlight of the book is the section on the Second
World War. Pogonowski's personal experience of the war no doubt enables him to narrate many events with a rare authenticity and authority. The book describes the Nazi invasion of 1939 in detail and discusses the effects of the German occupation on the press, art and literature. This section is narrated with precise dates and statistics, and the result is a gripping account of the war that commands the reader's attention.

To cover such an expansive period of history in so few pages, one must necessarily prioritize the most important information, sometimes at the expense of narrative coherence. In several instances, the book simply lists historical events as if they were self-explanatory. For example, Pogonowski writes "President Carter stated that his national security advisor would be Polish-born Dr. Zbigniew Brzeziński" (239), without discussing the significance or implications of such a choice. Whether this frequent lack of coherence is a result of space limitations is unclear, but one-sentence paragraphs and a lack of transitions are common throughout the book. Consequently, Pogonowski often leaves ideas and arguments underdeveloped and sometimes his paragraphs lack a logical flow.

The book provides a solid starting point for those seeking an introduction to Polish history, but it is not detailed enough for scholars to use as a reference. In contrast to existing accounts of Polish history, such as Norman Davies's God's Playground (Columbia UP, 1982), Pogonowski's book cites other works only sporadically and has no bibliography. Furthermore, the author sometimes abandons the historian's ideal of objectivity and strays into subjectivity. For example, we see the phrase "parasitic growth of Prussia at Poland's expense" by the map of the 1795 partition (147). Pogonowski's diction sometimes reveals a pro-Poland bias and his desire to portray Poland as a victim. This is especially apparent in the book's conclusion, where he states, "Poland is here to stay, judging by the performance of Polish culture which is of considerable importance to Europe, flourishing as it does in the physical center of the European continent" (253).

The book rightfully claims to be an illustrated history, as it contains facsimiles of numerous paintings and photographs. Additionally, many charts and maps are reprinted from Pogonowski's earlier book, Poland: A Historical Atlas (Hippocrene Books, 1987). They are convenient and show the author's meticulous work, though the charts tend to include details that can distract from the main issue. For example, the map of the final partition in 1795 includes information of the Polish gentry's rise and fall, and on how the Polish Commonwealth had the greatest freedom in Europe (147). The book concludes with a list of "Nobel Prize Winners Born in Poland" and a "Chronology of Poland's History." Helpful though they are, the lists are also at times misleading. Nobel Laureate Czesław Miłosz, for instance, was born in modern-day Lithuania -- then part of the Russian empire -- not in Poland.

The book would have benefited from better editing, which would have caught such errors as the misdating of Stanisław Wyspiański's life (it is dated in a caption 1846-1916, rather than the correct 1869-1907 (189)) and the Seven Years War (printed as 1758-1763 instead of 1756-1763 (122)). Furthermore, Polish diacritics are often misprinted: Łódź as Łódż (230, 238), Pożegnanie as Poźegnanie (136), Jędrzej as Jedrzej (197), and Przegląd as Przeglad (184). The book is also not free of typographical errors: Gdańsk as "Gdański" (237) and Balloon as "Baloon" (208) are just two examples.

Overall, it would be most appropriate to treat this book as a starting point rather than an authoritative source of information about Polish history. Even though it has shortcomings, it is ideal for those with little to no knowledge of the subject matter. It is easy to read, and the graphs and maps certainly make the fact-filled narrative more interesting. Finally, this book makes a strong case for anyone who has doubts about Poland's significance in Europe.

Tony H. Lin, University of California, Berkeley
14 lipiec 2010

przysłał ICP 

  

Komentarze

 

1. The presentation by Mr ICP himself such a critical review of his own work shows his integrity and professionalism.
2. While right at pointing material and editing errors (noticeble in other ICP' works as well), the critic failed to focus on the unique approach of ICP in such essential areas as role of Jews in Polish history or exposing antiPolish slanders and stereotypes so common in the USA. The latter makes ICP vulnerable to groundless accusations of bias.
3. The area covered in the book is so extensive that some simplifications are unavoidable. Moreover, the book isn't addressed to leading scholars, but rather to well educated US citizens. They may be well educated by US standards, but... Mr ICP is aware of their shortcomings.
4. Even though I was brough up as a Pole, I lost interest in Polish history long ago. Poland ceased to exist through a process of long gradual decay. It is a sad story that only few Poles share my opinions, therefore, I do not identify myself as a Pole anymore. Hence my opinion on the latest ICP's book is no partisan by any means.
5. The other mentioned book, Jews in Poland, seems to be much more intertesting from my point of view. Many predict the fall of American Empire coming soon. It's worthwhile to understand mentality of a small nation who had such a tremendous impact on rise and fall of several empires. In this regard, I would compare that book to 200 YEARS TOGETHER by Alexander Solzenitzin
http://www.wprost.pl/ar/135700/Pogrzeb-Aleksandra-Solzenicyna/?K=1&KI=55930
I commented upon the book at the time of Alecander Solzenitzin's burial. No doubt Mr Tony H. Lin, University of California, Berkeley is aware that same Jewish milieus in the US declared 200 YEARS TOGETGER as the worst book whenever written by whomever. Worse than MEIN KAMPF by adollf Hitler or LENIN by Antoni Ferdynand Ossendowski.
Mr ICP may consolate himself that his book on Jews in Poland will be found slightly better by the same people...


tłumacz, wynarodowiony

  

Archiwum

Anti-Communist Gorbatchev as the "Holy Terminator" of Russia
styczeń 17, 2005
Marek Glogoczowski
Traktat o Odnowie Solidarności Narodowej
maj 23, 2005
przesłała Elżbieta
Walka trwa
listopad 4, 2003
Andrzej Kumor
Edukacja
padziernik 10, 2006
Artur Łoboda
Jak latano 20 000 lat temu
lipiec 20, 2008
...
Nie chcą Leclerca
padziernik 3, 2005
przesłała Elżbieta
Francesco Cossiga i zamach na World Trade Center
styczeń 17, 2008
Marek P.
Demon-kracja czy demokracja
kwiecień 15, 2003
Adam Wielomski
Emigrujcie mlodzi, zrobcie miejsce
maj 6, 2004
Elzbieta
Znale?ć człowieka
grudzień 5, 2006
Artur Łoboda
Nowomowa
czerwiec 23, 2008
PAP
Szaron: Arafat to przywódca gangu morderców
sierpień 9, 2002
IAR
List otwarty do p. A. Słonimskiego
luty 13, 2004
Adam Doboszyński
Zespół do Spraw Reintegracji
listopad 27, 2002
PAP
Czy Amerykanie sami sobie zadali klęskę?
marzec 28, 2008
Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski
Germans, not Poles, the Main Killers of Jews of Jedwabne, Radzilow, etc.
kwiecień 12, 2008
przysłał ICP
Branie na litość
wrzesień 10, 2003
Andrzej Kumor
LIST OTWARTY
lipiec 22, 2003
mars
Rebelia w afgańskiej prowincji
czerwiec 18, 2004
PAP
Ogólnokrajowa DEMONSTRACJA PRZECIW WOJNIE Z IRAKIEM!
luty 7, 2003
 


Kontakt

Fundacja Promocji Kultury
Copyright © 2002 - 2012 Polskie Niezależne Media